Welcome To Zelo Street!

This is a blog of liberal stance and independent mind

Tuesday, 1 September 2015

Toby Young Privilege Hypocrisy

One unwritten rule for the less sharp tools in the right-wing commentary box is that there must be regular ridicule and denunciation of anyone and anything to do with the deeply subversive Guardian. Some of the paper’s writers attract an especial kind of nastiness, with George Monbiot and Polly Toynbee perhaps the most frequently targeted. The latest snipe at Ms Toynbee has come from the loathsome Toby Young.
(c) Doc Hackenbush 2014

Tobes has taken particular exception to her latest article, “Let Queen Elizabeth reign until the end – then stop this charade”, on the Royal Family, which concludes with the firmly Republican sentiment “Put an end to this royal infantalising of a nation. Imagine how abolishing the monarchy would open all the dusty constitutional cupboards to the sunlight of reform. Let her reign as long as she lives – but let her be Elizabeth the Last”.
Another grown-up perspective from Tobes

Being a good Tory and unswerving Royalist, Tobes could not let this heresy go unpunished. In a bizarre Twitter excursion, he asserted “Let the present queen’s reign mark the end of this privileged dynasty, say [sic] @pollytoynbee. Pot, kettle, black?” above a representation of an edited Toynbee family tree. What relevance does this have to the Royal Family? Well, none, actually. Other Tweeters were unimpressed.
The condemnation was not backward in coming forward: “What a ridiculous comparison … Jealousy can be a terrible thing … What on earth is your point? @pollytoynbee's family has many notable members. Good for them, they earned it each generation”. Indeed they did: one might think that Tobes is a teensy bit jealous, rather than accepting that he was not even good enough to be a regular columnist at the Sun.
And, as the man said, there was more: “that's... not even a little bit similar. What is wrong with you? You're like the dumbest smart person … Pretty sure the Toynbees aren't as privileged as the Windsors. Also they actually work for a living”. Then came the pièce de résistance: “That may well be the most stupid comparison, you've ever made (and there is stiff competition)”. Give that Tweeter a Cheeto!
On top of that, if we’re talking privilege, which is the heavy hint that Tobes is making, he is standing in an extremely draughty glasshouse here. As the son of Michael Young, Baron Young of Dartington, the Labour peer who drafted the party’s 1945 manifesto “Let Us Face The Future”, Tobes is entitled to call himself not just plain old Toby Young, but the Honorable Toby Daniel Moorsom Young.
All of which means that what we have here is a total lack of credibility for someone, and that someone is not Polly Toynbee. Guardian pundits do not need to ask Tobes’ permission to go about their business without being personally smeared for their trouble. There is a strong Republican tradition in Britain, and despite the entreaties of the tabloid press, such a stance does not make its adherents traitorous or disloyal.

What does it make Tobes? Full value for his nickname of Captain Bellend, that’s what.


Anonymous said...

If Toby Jug had the wherewithal he'd be looking at the ancient Toynbee connection to the notorious Milner Group. Not that softshite would have the slightest idea who and what they were. Or that they had nothing whatever to do with dear old Polly.

I have no time whatever for the current Toynbee or the Guardian, whose latter fall from grace has been little short of media tragic, while her attacks on Jeremy Corbyn have been sickening.

But on the question of the unelected, dysfunctional Windsors and their Ruritanian existence...I am on Toynbee's side. Get rid of the lot of them and make them work for a living. They're as relevant and as feudal as a nineteenth century Prussian Diet - you know, like the House of Lords.

And the Bullingdon gang, New Labour and the LibDems have the hypocritical cheek to talk about "British democracy." Christ, you have to larf.

Gonzoland said...

What the prat has done is take a snipe at Polly Toynbee for having the sheer audacity to be a daughter, grand-daughter and great-grand-daughter.

Anonymous said...

Toby Young is the Pitts.

Arnold said...

Nobody will ever reign as long in future. All we can look forward to is a string of octogenarian monarchs who may reign for no more than ten or twenty years. And Charles will never be popular. It'd downhill all the way now, and time to call a halt.