Welcome To Zelo Street!

This is a blog of liberal stance and independent mind

Sunday 31 March 2019

Leave EU Seeks Its Gabby Giffords Moment

During 2010, former US Vice Presidential nominee Sarah Palin, via her Political Action Committee, went after several Democrat Representatives over their advocacy for Barack Obama’s health care reforms. To promote this campaign, SarahPAC put out a graphic, telling “20 House Democrats from districts we carried in 2008 voted for the Health Care Bill  … IT’S TIME TO TAKE A STAND”. The “targets” were picked out with gunsight crosshairs.
One of those targeted was Gabrielle Giffords, then representing Arizona’s 8th District. A week into her third term, while she was hosting a “Congress on your corner” event - a constituency surgery - at a Safeway supermarket near Tucson, she was shot by Jared Lee Loughner. Several others were killed; many more were wounded. The Palin PAC took down its graphic. But it was too late. The incendiary rhetoric had a body count.
The lessons of the Giffords shooting have, sadly, gone unheeded, and not just in the USA. Here in the UK, during the febrile atmosphere of the 2016 EU referendum campaign, we had our own Gabby Giffords moment as Labour MP Jo Cox was murdered outside her constituency surgery by far-right activist Thomas Mair.
After the shooting: Gabby Giffords and Barack Obama

The consequences of dialling up the rhetoric, along with aggressive propagandising, are all too clear - but not to the convocation of inconsiderate bigotry otherwise known as Leave EU, where the kind of campaigning that led to the Giffords shooting is in full swing. The only difference is that, as we have strict gun control laws, gunsight crosshairs are out. Instead, Leave EU have used crude crosses. In red. In the shape of a crucifix.
Jo Cox

You think I jest? Here’s the offending Tweet, telling “Our deselection campaign to boot the worst Tory Remoaners had a big victory last night against ringleader Dominic Grieve - and we're just getting started. Let's save Brexit!” and showing those crucifix-styled crosses over the heads of Anna Souby, Heidi Allen and Sarah Wollaston (all of whom have resigned from the Tory Party), as well as Nick Boles and Dominic Grieve.
The latter two MPs have lost confidence votes held by their local Conservative associations. Next on the Leave EU list is Oliver Letwin, and after him comes Antoinette Sandbach, who represents the Cheshire constituency of Eddisbury. With Leave EU howling after them “Tory Remainers are terrified of their grassroots members rising up and deselecting them after our successful campaigns against Dominic Grieve, Nick Boles, and Sarah Wollaston. Betraying the will of the people has consequences!
Betrayal. Targeting. Blood-red crucifix-style crosses. The memory of what happened outside a Safeway supermarket in 2011. The memory of what happened outside Birstall library in 2016. And there go Nigel Farage, Arron Banks, Andy Wigmore, Richard Tice and their chums ratcheting up the hatred just for laughs.

If it’s time for anything right now, it’s time not for aggressive and hateful propagandising - it’s time to put the rhetoric away. Before the next Jared Lee Loughner or Thomas Mair crawls out of the woodwork intent on striking a blow for history.

Leave EU is a stain on grown-up politics. It’s time to reach for the disinfectant.
Enjoy your visit to Zelo Street? You can help this truly independent blog carry on talking truth to power, while retaining its sense of humour, by adding to its Just Giving page at


Arnold said...

"Wonder if Cameron ever looks at footage of people dragging effigies of Sadiq Khan & Theresa May around by their necks and thinks “hmm maybe I do regret calling the referendum a bit”"


England is certainly a far uglier place than it was 3 years ago.

Anonymous said...

Disinfectant won't clean up forty years of deliberately manufactured poverty, division, propaganda, institutional corruption and greed. The malaise of lies and self deception runs too deep.

This country long ago ossified into what one author described as "A litter-strewn right wing authoritarian rat-hole". But even that is too kind.

The next general election will bring a chance - and that's all it will be, A CHANCE - to try to reverse this horror. If Corbyn gets elected with sufficient majority the first 100-200 days will be crucial for impetus of genuine change. Before and after he will be faced with a disgusting propaganda barrage unprecedented even by the "standards" of current far right monopoly ownership of corporate media, to say nothing of probable internal treachery and betrayal by the usual suspects.

So far, he and McDonnell have surprised everybody with their staying power and political nous. But if they lose the election or falter in government the future of this country will be bleak indeed. In which case we might as well sell everything to Yank and European spivs and settle for being a nation of corrupt, self-deluded pimps with no sense of individual or collective pride.

No, there isn't and never will be enough disinfectant on the planet to clean out the stench of the last forty years of dry rot. Only a long term course of injections of common sense decency will do that. Looking at how far British socioeconomic culture has fallen, what odds would you give for that likelihood?

AndyC said...

Jacinda Ardern has the right idea. Dont give murderers the fame they crave. She refuses to call the assassin in NZ by his name. I would be happy never to hear again the name of the fascist who killed Jo Cox, or the nazi who shot Gabby Gifford, or the Norwegian fascist POS who killed so many young people. Remember and mourn their terrible deeds, but dont give any acknowledgement to the killers.

sigil said...

If Corbyn can be vilified for his Facebook account inadvertently supporting a picture in which the possession of money and a big nose signalled antisemitism to some, I'm sure it'll be fine to point out that these advancing, Crusading St George crosses are reminiscent of many a BNP-style website's adornments.

Tim Clark said...

I totally agree. And this should start in sites like this.