Welcome To Zelo Street!

This is a blog of liberal stance and independent mind

Sunday 8 March 2015

Don’t Menshn TV Debates

[Update at end of post]

What a difference a couple of days makes. Late last week, the Murdoch Times published a leader entitled “True Frit”, telling Young Dave he should join the TV Debates. The next day, the paper had completed a U-Turn and was now telling “Sheer Arrogance … in the debate on the debates, the broadcasters have gone too far”. Now, right across Creepy Uncle Rupe’s empire, everyone has agreed that TV Debates are A Very Bad Thing Indeed.
That, inevitably, brings us to yet another spectacular U-Turn, this time by (thankfully) former Tory MP Louise Mensch, now representing the distant constituency of Manhattan Upmarket, whose column in Sunday’s Sun is unequivocally titled “Switch Off TV Debates”. She goes on “Chicken on the TV debates? No, David Cameron is showing good sense - and we should ditch such debates for ever”. And there’s more - much more.
The first TV debates harmed our Government for the past five years”. As they happened before the election, that would be an interesting idea (and see what she said at the time below). “We don’t need a leader’s debate that’s a glorified version of PMQs” she continues, seemingly oblivious of what Young Dave told Pa Broon in 2008: “I have to say to the Prime Minister that if he really thinks that these exchanges once a week are a substitute for a proper television debate, then he is even more out of touch than I thought”.
But Ms Mensch is sure of her ground: “If anything, David Cameron’s mistake was not saying ‘no debates’ in 2010 … after this election he should make it clear that no TV debates will happen again”. In fact, what Dave did say wasI’ve always wanted these debates to happen. I mean they happen in every country. They even happen in Mongolia for heaven’s sake and it’s part of the modern age that we should be in”.
And there is another teensy problem with Ms Mensch’s current attitude to TV Debates - her own enthusiasm for them last time round, which has been preserved on Twitter. In reply to one enquiry on poll leads, she replied “if you believe fantasy leads of 26% or 2%. Last several polls all show growing Tory leads. Bookies cut odds on Tories post debate”. Debates cut odds on a Tory victory? They were clearly A Very Good Thing.
They were a “must-watch”, too: “Am off to an activists' meeting. Hope I'm back in time for the leaders' debate… “ she enthused. Later there was the breathless exclamation “BREAKING: Cameron wins debate according to YouGov poll...only just....more soon”. TV Debates weren’t such a bad thing then, were they? There was no talk of Dave being in favour being some kind of mistake, was there?
No sirree: “And that's why Cameron leads the party...won the debate under pressure in the only non-voodoo, weighted poll. #leadersdebate … So, front pages today all showing Cameron the winner of the second debate. Great stuff”. Yes, in 2010 Louise Bagshawe (as she was then) said TV Debates were “Great stuff”. Now the same person says Dave was mistaken in accepting those debates - that he had been advocating for years previously.

Doesn’t that make Ms Mensch a stinking hypocrite? Yes, but no more than usual.

[UPDATE 9 March 1400 hours: a Zelo Street regular has pointed out that Ms Mensch's enthusiasm for TV Debates extends back into 2009, and that there are particularly good Twitter examples of this.
Take this example, from February of that year: "Clegg and Cameron now both agreed to Sky Leaders' Debate. Ohh Gorrrdoon ... can you hearrrr me ... earth to MacCavity" she sneers, ensuring a very warm reception should she ever venture north of Hadrian's Wall.
She was still enthusing in June, telling "ah ... must be the #leadersdebate. It will be amusing watching all the Labour Twitterers backtrack as to why a Sky debate is now a great idea".

Two birds killed with one stone, eh? Labour given a kicking, and Creepy Uncle Rupe gets his ego massaged into the bargain. Pity about the hostage to fortune, eh?]


rob said...

Come gather 'round people
Whatever you've read
And admit that the Mensch
Has been forcefully fed
By a diet of Murdoch
To whom she's greatly in hock.
If your time to you
Is worth savin'
Then you better start thinking '
'bout reading som'thin' else
For The Sun is not a-changin'.

Come writers and critics
Who proselytise with your pen
Readers get wise to tarts
Trying to fool us again
And don't speak too glib
With all of your spin
For there's no tellin' who
That it's a shamin'.
For the loser now
Will be later to win
And The Sun is not a-changin'.

Alasdair said...

I'm not sure why anyone pays any attention to anything Mensch says: she's a failed politician with a brief, unsuccessful career, who as I understand it doesn't even live in this country. The few times she's had some kind of impact have been for being publicly wrong about something. She has as much relevance and credibility to British politics as Sarah Palin.

Steven Reid said...


Dylan would be proud.

Well done Tim on the research..Mensch is so obvious in her self interested pronouncements and her com temp for the public….


rob said...

Update from The Sun:

Everybody's reading a new Sun troll, now
(Come on baby, do the flipperty flop)
You might just get to like it if you give it a chance now
(Come on baby, do the flipperty flop)
L'il Louise Mensch can do it with ease
It's easier than learning Gove's A-B-C's
So come on, come on, do the flipperty flop with me

You might twist your facts, now
Come on, baby
Upside down
It's a blast
Well, now, I think you've forgotten the past
Wow, wow

Now that you can do it, let's make a column, now
(Come on baby, do the flipperty flop)
Help Thomas Newton Dunn to score an own goal, now
(Come on baby, do the flipperty flop)
Do it nice and easy, now, you don't need much care
A little bit of rhetoric and plain and simple fare
Come on, come on
Do the flipperty flop with me