Welcome To Zelo Street!

This is a blog of liberal stance and independent mind

Monday 9 August 2021

Climate Emergency - Greta v Guido

For those who have claimed that it wasn’t happening, that there was nothing to worry about, and we should therefore carry on our lifestyles as before, the moment of reality has now arrived. To no surprise at all, the report from the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change already has the denialists digging their heels in. Nothing to see here. Again.

It's got worse since 2008, too

But, as the BBC has reported, “‘Today's IPCC Working Group 1 Report is a code red for humanity,’ said UN Secretary-General, António Guterres. ‘If we combine forces now, we can avert climate catastrophe. But, as today's report makes clear, there is no time for delay and no room for excuses. I count on government leaders and all stakeholders to ensure COP26 is a success’”. So what do campaigners make of that?

Who to believe, Greta ...

Greta Thunberg mostly agrees. “The new IPCC report contains no real surprises. It confirms what we already know from thousands previous studies and reports - that we are in an emergency. It’s a solid (but cautious) summary of the current best available science … It doesn't tell us what to do. It is up to us to be brave and take decisions based on the scientific evidence provided in these reports. We can still avoid the worst consequences, but not if we continue like today, and not without treating the crisis like a crisis”.

... or The Great Guido?

Of those who have browsed the report, Peter Stefanovic, he of the video that has had 30 million views but of which the BBC dare not speak its name, has concluded “The report warns that even in the best case scenarios, some changes are already locked in to our systems, including sea level rise. This will never be reversed, not even under the lowest emissions scenario. We can still avoid the worst consequences but only if we act NOW”.

Sadly, though, it is not just about following the science, as Carole Cadwalladr has warned: “Today's report is utterly damning & utterly unequivocal. It's also not enough. The political forces seeking to undermine solutions are dark, powerful & organised. Tech platforms that spread disinfo are out of control. Science, alone, is not enough”.

Just how powerful and organised the denial brigade is right now can be seen by the response from the perpetually thirsty Paul Staines and his rabble at the Guido Fawkes blog, from whom many in our free and fearless press will take their cue. There, the line isUN Has Been Predicting Planetary Disaster For 50 Years … UN’s Fifty Years Of Eco-Doom Warnings … Don’t believe the doomsters. Don’t bet against humanity’s ingenuity”.

Yes, don’t worry, carry on as before, drive everywhere (Staines excepted), sling lots of red meat down yer throat, go on lots of long haul holidays (more on this later from Julia Hartley Dooda), burn lots of solid fuel, keep the thermostat turned up, sneer at wind and wave power, and above all make sure you tell the Rotten Greenies™ that it’s all about FREEM!

Capitalism, we will be told, should be left to itself and by doing so, disaster will be averted. The problem, as The Affluent Society pointed out back in the 1950s, is that capitalism, left to itself, does some things very well, but others badly. And what it does badly is to give a damn about the environment. Someone else has to clear up the mess.

Well, now it’s not just the mess. It’s the planet. All of it. And there isn’t another one we can just go and inhabit. The denialists - organised and powerful - will sing their siren song once more and demonise the Gretas of this world. And more denial will end very badly indeed.

Enjoy your visit to Zelo Street? You can help this truly independent blog carry on talking truth to power, while retaining its sense of humour, by adding to its Just Giving page at



Anonymous said...

koch brothers!

Anonymous said...

With great respect to JK Galbraith, capitalism does fuck all "very well" except destroy human lives AND the environment.

Ed said...

UN [actually the world's scientists, underwritten by the world's governments]Has Been Predicting Planetary Disaster For 50 Years [maybe not quite that long in this form] … UN’s Fifty Years Of Eco-Doom Warnings … Don’t believe the doomsters. Don’t bet against humanity’s ingenuity [we depend precisely on human ingenuity, which is a long way from what Fawkes is exhibiting]

Arnold said...

The Mail is sitting on the fence.

'Code Red for humanity': Doomsday UN report says global warming is ALREADY causing extreme weather and the world will heat up by 1.5C by 2040 - a decade earlier than forecast

DOMINIC LAWSON: Why IS the BBC a pulpit for eco-fanatics and their doomsday climate cult?
Obligatory BBC bashing. But someone's due for a bollocking for omitting the word "woke".

secret squirrel said...

If I might disagree, I think that capitalism would deal with climate change very well. The problem is that the climate costs are not factored in. Without considering these costs, capitalism blunders around, destroying stuff as usual.

It's at this point that economists – including experienced and eminent personalities such as Nigel Lawson – should tell us how to include environmental costs in a capitalist system. Some of them do, but the most prominent deniers don't.

Too much effort, basically. Why bother to do some work, when you can just slag off somebody else's work, without any knowledge or expertise? I know it's all ideology, but the shameful side of it is the intellectual laziness.

So it all comes back to ideology, and we'll have to see if the 18 year old Greta Thunberg, or the 89 year old Nigel Lawson will carry the day. Time will tell.

Anonymous said...

"Climate costs" haven't been "factored in" for almost four centuries of capitalist wars, imperialism, inflicted poverty home and abroad, fascism, Nazism, falangism, theocracy, dying feudalism, the factory system, land theft, river pollution and propaganda.

So, "factoring in environmental costs" is about as likely to improve society as a chocolate fireguard on Evia.

Anonymous said...

Wifebeater stans also repopped up on behalf of the friendsofwifebeaters over the recent ‘save our emus’ campaign … dodgy old scroat