Welcome To Zelo Street!

This is a blog of liberal stance and independent mind

Thursday 3 June 2021

Julie Burchill On Anti-Semitism? Er, No

In an editorial decision that will surprise no-one, the increasingly alt-right Spectator magazine has given Islamophobic pundit Julie Burchill a platform to pontificate on the subject of anti=Semitism, on which she is eminently well-qualified, but not necessarily for the reasons she would have us believe. The targets of her ire are younger and far better off than she is, but this is not an example of embittered jealousy, oh no.

Julie Burchill

The resulting article, “The problem with Palestine’s showbiz supporters”, presses all the right (well, alt-right, anyway) buttons in its first line: “One of the many reasons I hate wokers is because they indulge so shamelessly in what Bebel coined ‘the socialism of fools’ - anti-Semitism - under the convenient cover of sticking up for the Palestinians”.

Judaism and the State of Israel ...
... are not the same thing. Know the difference

And it is here where Ms Burchill - predictably - goes wrong, equating criticism of the state of Israel with anti-Semitism. Predictably, because she has been here before, of which more later. Moreover, the IHRA definition of anti-Semitism makes clear that equating Jews with Israel is in itself anti-Semitic, and Ms Burchill has been there before, too.


Not even the folks at the Jewish Chronicle are prepared to give her a free pass, as Lee Harpin showed when he observed “Julie Burchill's decision to turn to Tabatha Stirling,of Stirling Publishing, to bring out her latest book is beyond the pale. In recordings made as Miss Brittania, Stirling's racism, antisemitism and homophobia is there to be heard. As is her support for Patriotic Alternative”. And her explicit anti-Semitism is worse.


As Nathan Oseroff-Spicer discovered when he read Ms Burchill’s book “Unchosen: The Memoirs of a Philo-Semite”, it wasn’t exactly difficult to find. She said of her copy of the Torah “we cut our thumbs, smeared our mixed blood on the title page and he agreed with me that ‘Now we’re with them, whatever happens’”. Oseroff-Spicer asked “You're telling me Julie Burchill claims to have desecrated the most sacred object in Judaism?


He referenced one passage in the Burchill tome thus: “For the edification of non-Jews reading this passage, this is not philo-Semitism, the purported love of Jews, but rather two clear cases of antisemitism, i.e. (1) asserting the state of Israel is identical to Jewish identity and (2) no one is genuinely Jewish by choice”. And there was more.


Noting Ms Burchill’s claim “Considering that so many Muslim movements fought on the side of the Fascists during the [Second World] War”, he added “She's gonna lift the top off her cranium when she finds out about all the non-Muslims who sided with the fascists, you know, like the majority of people who sided with the fascists”. Well, quite.


The Tweeter known as Jews Sans Fronti√®res has recently reminded us of another unfortunate incident from Ms Burchill’s back catalogue: "Having said I shouldn't indulge flagrantly racist Julie Burchill I didn't realise she drew inspiration from the Nazis. Calling a woman she is baiting for being a Muslim, a SOW, is truly inspired stuff from the deepest roots of German antisemitism”. Yet there is the Speccy giving her a platform.


And there is the Speccy’s head man Andrew Neil Tweeting out a link to the article. It’s almost as if some people don’t actually understand anti-Semitism - they just talk about it.

Julie Burchill has no room to call anti-Semitism on others. Given she’s done it herself.


Enjoy your visit to Zelo Street? You can help this truly independent blog carry on talking truth to power, while retaining its sense of humour, by adding to its Just Giving page at

https://www.justgiving.com/crowdfunding/zelostreet9

7 comments:

Anonymous said...

Burchill's problem is that she's an utter idiot.

Always was, always will be.

Anonymous said...

https://www.theguardian.com/theguardian/1999/oct/16/weekend7.weekend6

Vile vile woman

James said...

Just had a look at the Guardian article referenced above...and wow. Just wow. Such a heartless text. How could they publish that ?! And they still are treating Burchill like a legitimate person instead of a grade A, identity politics driven bigot.

Anonymous said...

If her "writing" is anything to go by she's a very strange individual indeed. She actually seems full of hatred and resentment for people. Not so much a chip on her shoulder as a rock in her head. Then again, all too typical of dominant psychopathic media "culture". A perfect co-ordinator for the dominant political class.

Anonymous said...

Just looking at the photo of Burchill....Ive never seen her in the same room as Sarah Gove

Anonymous said...

Philo-Semites are just anti-Semites pulled inside-out. They both share the same stereotyped views of Jews, but the former proclaim their undying love for them on that false basis, rather than despise them as with the latter. One way or the other, it's racialised politics, something to be strongly opposed.

Dr Paul

Jonathan said...

Julie Burchill sadly like many out there on the Alt Right scene are chancers,liars and grifters.

The use of the lazy term 'woke' is no different from the 'looney Left' label banded about by Burchill, Neil and others for those of us concerned about those without a voice.

Surprised she hasn't gone studs in on Naomi Osaka for putting the needs of tennis players mental health above giving corporate media interviews..