Welcome To Zelo Street!

This is a blog of liberal stance and independent mind

Friday, 13 November 2020

EHRC Devalued By Bigot Appointment

The Equality and Human Rights Commission, we have been told by a never-ending succession of hacks and pundits, is the gold standard when it comes to promoting and protecting equality and non-discrimination. Its investigation into allegations of anti-Semitism in the Labour Party is cited as evidence of this high standard, which is upheld by the EHRC’s Board of Commissioners, with backgrounds in equality and human rights.

So it was most interesting to read a Government press release this week that toldToday (12 November) the Minister for Women and Equalities, Liz Truss, has appointed four new Commissioners to the Board of the Equality and Human Rights Commission (EHRC) … Jessica Butcher MBE, David Goodhart and Su-Mei Thompson have been appointed to the Board for a period of four years”. Lord Ribeiro will join the Board for just one year.

And the name that leaps off that particular page is that of David Goodhart. He is, let us not drive this around the houses for too long, a racist bigot. And, as Middle East Eye has reported, “The UK government has appointed a supporter of its ‘hostile environment’ policy as a commissioner on its equalities watchdog, the EHRC, which is currently investigating the Home Office over the linked Windrush scandal in which hundreds of people from Black and ethnic minorities were wrongly deported”.

There is more. “Goodhart has also questioned complaints of systemic racism in the UK raised by the Black Lives Matter movement. Writing for the Unherd website in June, he described those complaints as ‘statistically naive’”. Goodhart has complained “that he had ‘grown used to being accused of racism, even by my own children’”.

David Goodhart

It gets worse: Goodhart, who tells anyone prepared to listen that he is from the “liberal centre-left”, asserted in 2004 thatTo put it bluntly, most of us prefer our own kind”. He has claimed that immigration is “pretty unpopular”, and after the 2010 General Election, declared that “Labour must become the anti-immigration party”.

His concluding remark on that occasion was “Labour must close the door”. The following year, Operation Black Vote asked “David Goodhart: more dangerous than Nick Griffin?” That was after Goodhart had concluded “I am now convinced that public opinion is right and Britain has had too much immigration too quickly”. And he wasn’t finished.

By the time of the next census in 2021, the non-white minority population will have risen to around 20 per cent, a trebling in just 25 years. By 2066, according to one demographer, white Britons will be in a minority”. The difference between that andIn this country in 15 or 20 years' time the black man will have the whip hand over the white man” is not so great.

Small wonder the Institute of Race Relations’ spokesman has concluded “If there was any previous doubt, the appointment of David Goodhart as an EHRC commissioner, a man who has in the past attacked diversity and opined about the need to understand ‘majority grievances’, suggests the very real danger of an end to a progressive equalities agenda in this country”. Goodhart’s appointment, coupled with the EHRC’s refusal to investigate racism in the Tory Party, devalues the Commission, perhaps fatally.

The integrity of the EHRC was for a time, but not for all time. I’ll just leave that one there.

Enjoy your visit to Zelo Street? You can help this truly independent blog carry on talking truth to power, while retaining its sense of humour, by adding to its Just Giving page at



Rosie said...

Whitewash. Literally! EHRC has no credibility.

Ferdy Fox said...

Maybe Goodhart (surely a misnomer) should listen to his kids.

Anonymous said...

The Goodhart "appointment" can only be likened to Bliar's "appointment" as a Middle East "peace envoy".

Moral corruption is now so blatant even the most naive sandal-wearer must be starting to wonder where this will all finish up.

Jonathan said...

EHRC that bastion of all, which gave Corbyn a good duffing over whilst turning blind eye to Tory Islamophobia, claiming the Tories promises on an internal review was good enough!

Ordure, Ordure said...

Over half Muslim Labour members 'do not trust party to tackle Islamophobia' - The Guardian 14 Nov 2020
Expect another sloppy inquiry and sloppy report from the EHRC.
Expect Starmer to cry 'Labour's shame'.
Expect some people to say that the EHRC is nothing more than a tool of the Tory Party.
Expect nothing from the media.