The latest
jolly good wheeze cooked up by London’s occasional Mayor Alexander Boris de
Pfeffel Johnson, in another of his £5,000 generating
stream-of-sort-of-consciousness ramblings for the Maily Telegraph, is to lower fares by giving some of those
hard-pressed punters a tax break, or, as it is otherwise known, currying favour
with the voters by getting them to forget who jacked the fares up in the first
place.
One person who is able to command right of reply in the Standard, and who needs no prompting on
fare levels, is former Labour Transport Secretary Andrew Adonis, and he
has passed severely adverse comment on Bozza’s record, including the vanity
cable car, and especially the vanity buses, which, as Darren
Johnson AM has reminded the Mayor, have just scored their first serious rear
platform injury.
Adonis makes comparisons between London and other European
cities on fare levels, and here on Zelo Street we’re always up for a
fact check, and so have looked at the numbers for three other large cities: Berlin,
Milan
and Madrid.
Single and day tickets are compared, the London transport mode being the
Underground and Zones used 1-4. Today’s headline exchange rate is £1 = €1.184.
Single Tickets
London: £5.50 Cash, £3.80 Oyster peak, £2.70 Oyster
off-peak
Berlin: €2.60, €2.20 (4-journey ticket)
Milan: €1.50, €1.38 (10-journey ticket)
Madrid: €2.00, €1.22 (10-journey ticket).
Day Tickets
London: £11 (peak), £8 (off-peak), Oyster equivalents
£10.60 and £7.70
Berlin: €6.70
Milan: €4.50
Madrid: €8.40
The only reason the Madrid day ticket is relatively expensive
is because it is marketed as a Tourist ticket. Whichever way you slice it,
London’s transport is a seriously expensive proposition by comparison even with
supposedly prosperous and expensive Germany. And the Metro coverage in cities
like Madrid, and Berlin with the U-bahn and S-bahn networks combined, is
arguably superior.
And as Adonis points out, what Bozza didn’t tell his readers
is that there is another inflation-busting fare rise coming down the track, and
scheduled for January. Giving out some kind of tax break is just a smokescreen
to divert attention from this, and the increasingly large sums of money being
sprayed up the wall on Bozza’s vanity projects, which could be invested in more
worthwhile ways elsewhere.
This Mayor is wasting Londoners’ money. He should not be
allowed to get away with bluster and excuses. A responsible newspaper would not give him the platform.
an interesting idea from Boris - stolen from Paris if I remember correctly!
ReplyDeleteAnd how exactly would it work in other English regions where you can't buy all-operator passes? Can you imagine it in Crewe as people juggled D&G and Arriva (and First if they wanted to go ANYWHERE after 20:35) - all of a sudden that simple application got complicated.